Owen McGuire, who lives beside the park, sued the city and a business run by Justin and Keri vanBlaricom in September.

The plan has prompted enthusiasm and skepticism among some residents, bubbling up fears about changes to the quiet, close-knit neighborhood.

The rejection marks an about-face by Roanoke city officials, who in 2021 began negotiating with Claytor family about buying the property.

Some who served in the position felt their advocacy for neighborhoods and residents conflicted with the city’s position on issues.

Owen McGuire and Freeda Cathcart of the Grandin Court Neighborhood Association were removed in a 63-25 vote.

Nearly two years after City Council earmarked American Rescue Plan Act funds for the idea, none has gone to a Gainsboro hub.

Residents expressed confusion and criticism over a report aimed at guiding the long-neglected neighborhood’s revitalization.